
KDP vs Traditional Publishing: What’s Best for Authors?
Pros, cons, and opportunities of KDP vs. traditional publishers. Updated comparison with data from the Spanish market.
Leer másKader Gómez
Co-Founder of Alavante, Book Marketing Specialist & Senior Developer.

Publishing on Amazon is free and accessible. Selling and building a career as an independent author is not. This is the key difference.
Amazon KDP (Kindle Direct Publishing) has democratized publishing. Anyone can upload a manuscript and have it for sale worldwide in under 48 hours, with no upfront investment. This ease of access is its greatest advantage and, paradoxically, its most dangerous trap.
The market is saturated. Simply publishing is no longer the goal; the real challenge is achieving sustained visibility and sales. Most new authors skip the strategic steps, and their books end up in Amazon's digital graveyard, without sales or reviews.
Self-publishing in 2025 is a business. It requires an entrepreneurial mindset, not just a writer's. You must understand the algorithm, your ideal reader, and the tools that will give you a competitive edge.
Key Stat: In 2023, 57% of Amazon sellers reported profit margins above 10%, and 28% exceeded 20%¹. This demonstrates the platform's potential if you treat it as a serious business.
Here, you'll learn the system, not just the steps. You'll discover how to validate your idea, optimize your book for the algorithm, and use metrics to scale your income.
Understanding the rules of the game is the first step to winning. KDP isn't just a platform to upload files; it's a complex ecosystem with its own growth levers.
How do royalties really work?
Amazon offers two main royalty rates for eBooks: 70% and 35%. To qualify for the 70% rate, your book must be priced between $2.99 and $9.99. Outside that range, or in certain territories, the royalty drops to 35%. For paperbacks, the formula is (60% of list price) - printing costs. It's crucial to use KDP's calculator to project your actual earnings.
Furthermore, you must decide between wide distribution or exclusivity with KDP Select. If you choose KDP Select, your eBook can only be sold on Amazon for 90-day periods. In return, you gain access to promotional tools like Kindle Deals, Free Book Promotions, and most importantly, enrollment in Kindle Unlimited (KU).
Kindle Unlimited allows subscribers to read your book for "free," and you get paid for every page read (KENP - Kindle Edition Normalized Pages). In 2025, for high-consumption genres like romance, thriller, or science fiction, KU accounts for over 50% of many authors' income.
The Amazon algorithm is your most important customer. Its goal is simple: to show shoppers the books they are most likely to buy. To get its attention, your launch must send the right signals: clicks, sales, and reviews.
This is the costliest mistake. Before writing a single word, you must confirm that there is an audience actively looking for the type of book you want to create. Don't assume your idea is good; validate it with data.
Use Amazon's search bar like a reader. Type in keywords from your niche and look at the auto-suggest results. Analyze the top 10-20 bestselling books: what titles do they use? what do their covers look like? what do the negative reviews say? Your book should fit into an existing category but offer a unique or superior angle.
Amazon is a search engine. Your product page must be optimized so that readers can find you. This includes:
Operating blindly is a recipe for failure. You need tools that provide real market data.
Once published, your job isn't over. Now the analysis and optimization phase begins. The KDP Dashboard is your command center. You should check it daily.
Which metrics really matter?
Don't just obsess over daily sales. Pay attention to trends. The KDP report shows you crucial data that you must interpret:
| Metric | What It Means | Action to Take |
|---|---|---|
| Royalty Sales | Breakdown of earnings by country and format. | Identify your strongest markets to focus your advertising. |
| KENP Read | Pages read by KU subscribers. | High KENP but low sales might mean your book is engaging, but the price is a barrier. Consider price adjustments or promotions. |
| Sales Rank (ABSR) | Your ranking in the store. A lower number is better. | Observe how promotions or ads affect your rank. A sustained rank below 10,000 indicates consistent sales. |
Use this data to make informed decisions. Did a Facebook ad campaign skyrocket your rank? Scale it. Did a change in your keywords tank your visibility? Revert the change.
What separates authors who make money from those who don't? Primarily, avoiding these strategic mistakes that sabotage even good books.
| Common Mistake | Symptom | Solution |
|---|---|---|
| Amateur Cover | Very low click-through rate. Ads don't convert. | Invest in a professional designer who specializes in book covers. It is your most important marketing tool. |
| Publishing Blind | Zero or near-zero sales after launch. | Before your next book, conduct thorough market research. Use tools like Publisher Rocket. |
| Ignoring Reviews | The book stalls after a few initial sales. | Ethically request reviews from your mailing list or social media. Negative reviews are feedback: use them to improve. |
| Not Building an Audience | Total dependence on the Amazon algorithm. | Start a mailing list from day one. Offer a lead magnet (a short story, a guide) to capture subscribers. |
In author communities, the advice is unanimous: your email list is the only asset you control. Amazon can change its algorithm tomorrow, but your list of readers will always be yours.
Self-publishing on Amazon KDP in 2025 remains one of the most profitable opportunities for writers, but success is no longer accidental. It requires a mindset shift: from artist to authorpreneur.
Stop thinking about "publishing a book" and start thinking about "launching a product." This involves researching your market, understanding your customer (the reader), creating a high-quality product (book and cover), and promoting it strategically.
Use data, not assumptions. Measure your performance, learn from your mistakes, and reinvest in what works. This is the path to building a sustainable career as an independent author on the world's largest platform.
1 RepricerExpress - 20 Amazon Statistics You Should Know in 2025
2 KDP Help Center - KDP Reports
3 KDP Help Center - Sales Dashboard
Did you like this article? Share it and continue the discussion on your networks.

Pros, cons, and opportunities of KDP vs. traditional publishers. Updated comparison with data from the Spanish market.
Leer más
Checklist and tips for your manuscript, cover, and Amazon KDP publishing in 2025. Includes free tools.
Leer más
Discover how a landing page builds your brand, drives sales, and connects you with readers. Real example: Juan Gómez-Jurado’s website.
Leer más